Mouthguard Too Thick or Uncomfortable? Causes and Fixes
You put your mouthguard in, and it feels like a hockey puck. You can't talk, breathing feels like work, and five minutes later it's in your hand instead of your mouth.
Here's the good news: an uncomfortable guard is almost always fixable, and the problem usually isn't how thick it is.
In this blog, you'll learn why your mouthguard feels too thick or uncomfortable, how to fix each cause, how to check your fit, and what to look for in a guard you'll actually want to wear.
6 Reasons Your Mouthguard Feels Uncomfortable (And How to Fix Each One)
Find the one that sounds like you. Each cause comes with an easy fix.
1. It Doesn't Fully Grip Your Teeth
If your guard drops when you open your mouth, you end up clenching or pushing it up with your tongue all game. That gets tiring fast, and it makes the guard feel way bigger than it is.
The fix: Remold it. Bite down gently, press the sides firmly against your teeth with your fingers, and suck out the air while it sets. Our step-by-step mouthguard fitting instructions walk you through it. With Goon Guard, the patented SmartForm™ material shrinks as it cools and locks onto your teeth, so it stays put without any clenching.
2. The Design Is Just Bulky
Some guards are simply built thick. You can mold them perfectly, and they'll still crowd your mouth, muffle your voice, and make it hard to grab a drink.
The fix: Go thinner. Every Goon Guard has a thin, low-profile design, so you can talk, breathe, and hydrate without taking it out.
3. The Back Edges Are Too Long
If your guard pokes your gums or makes you gag, the back ends are probably reaching too far into your mouth.
The fix: Trim the back edges with clean scissors, a little at a time, and try it on after each snip. Just make sure it still covers your back teeth.
4. You Bit Down Too Hard When Molding
Chomping down during molding can leave thin spots and an uneven surface. Then your bite feels off every time you close your mouth.
The fix: Remold it with a gentle bite, just enough to hold it in place. Let your fingers do the shaping, not your jaw.
5. Your Teeth Have Changed
Braces, a lost tooth, or a new one coming in can turn a great fit into a so-so one. The guard didn't get worse. Your mouth just changed.
The fix: Remold it to match your teeth today. Goon Guard is braces-compatible and remoldable as teeth shift, so one guard can keep up as your smile changes.
Playing in braces? Here's what athletes with braces should know about mouthguards.
6. It's Still Brand New
Anything new in your mouth feels a little strange at first. That's completely normal.
The fix: Give it a few practices, and wear it around the house for a bit too. A Goon Guard's SmartForm material also keeps settling for the next 24 hours after molding, so mold yours at least a day before game day.
Notice how most of these come back to fit? Get the fit right, and comfort usually follows.
How to Tell If Your Mouthguard Fits Right
Once you've made a fix, run these quick checks. A mouthguard that stays in place and feels right should pass every one:
-
Open wide: It stays on your top teeth without clenching.
-
Say a full sentence: Your teammates can understand you.
-
Take a sip: You can drink without pulling it out.
-
Run your tongue along the back: Nothing pokes your gums or makes you gag.
Missed one? No big deal. Remold it and try again.
What to Look for in a Comfortable Sports Mouthguard
If you're shopping for a new guard, comfort and fit go hand in hand. The best-fitting mouthguard is the one you forget is even there. Here's what to look for:
-
A locked-in fit that doesn't need clenching to stay put
-
A thin profile that lets you talk and drink
-
Easy remolding, so it keeps fitting as your teeth change
-
A strap only if your sport calls for it
That last one matters more than people think, because a strap near your chin can bug you if you don't need it. For hockey and football, the Goon Guard Strapped 2-Pack clips to your face mask, so your guard stays with you.
For wrestling, BJJ, MMA, boxing, and basketball, the Goon Guard Strapless 2-Pack keeps nothing outside your mouth. Both come with a spare, so there's always a backup in your bag.
FAQs
Why does my mouthguard make me gag?
Usually, the back edges reach too far. Trim them a little at a time, and make sure the guard still covers your back teeth.
Should a mouthguard feel tight?
It should feel snug, not painful. It should stay on your teeth without clenching. If it pinches or rubs, remold it. If it still hurts after that, check with your dentist.
Can you make a mouthguard thinner?
You can trim the length, but you can't really make a thick guard thin. If bulk is the problem, a thin, low-profile guard is the easier fix.
How long does it take to get used to a mouthguard?
For most people, a few practices. If it still feels off after that, run the fit checks above.
Why can't I talk with my mouthguard in?
A thick or loose guard is usually the reason. A thin guard that locks onto your teeth makes talking much easier.
Find Your Comfortable Fit With Goon Guard
A mouthguard that feels too thick or uncomfortable usually just needs a better fit. Remold it, trim the back edges if it makes you gag, and give a new guard a few practices to settle in.
If the guard itself is the problem, a thin one that locks onto your teeth makes all the difference. You can talk, breathe, and hydrate without taking it out, so it stays in your mouth where it belongs. It molds in seconds. No boiling. No impressions. No wait.
Ready for a guard you'll actually want to wear? Find the right Goon Guard for your sport.
